.
Feedback

Different Fates Await Elmhurst's Closed Shops

Lots of people have been talking about Fontano's, Kopper Kitchen and Good Earth Market. Here's the scoop.

Businesses on two high-profile corners in Elmhurst, and one downtown lunch spot, have all closed in recent months, causing customers to wonder, "What is going on behind the papered-up windows and the empty storefronts?" While some patrons will have to look for new favorite places to get a bite to eat, the news is not all bad.

A visit last week to Fontano's, 113 W. First St., revealed that the store was empty except for kitchen equipment. A sign on the front windows indicated the store is for lease, and it gave a phone number for Phillips Martin Real Estate.

Fontano's owner Kevin O'Keeffe said he had to close the shop because of the economy and the fact that more people are bringing their lunches to work and not eating out.

“I had to cut my losses,” he said, adding that closing the business affected him emotionally as well as monetarily. He estimated that he lost about $100,000 on the store.

O'Keeffe said the owners of the Fontano's franchise were looking into buying the store back and keeping it open. But in order to resume business, the DuPage County Health Department said another bathroom needed to be installed to meet codes established in the Americans with Disabilities Act. This, O'Keeffe said, was not possible within current footprint of the store.

O'Keeffe said that he loved owning the business and his customers were “incredible” and “loyal,” with some coming in two or three times each week.

At Good Earth Market, 555 S. York Road, windows on the main building are papered over, but a sign on York Road reads “Greenhouse open weekends.”

Bill Hogan with Good Earth confirmed that the greenhouse is now open weekends, and it will be open daily beginning the first Monday after Easter. In addition, he said the retail area will open around May 25. Currently, Hogan said, workers are expanding the store's cafe and deli area to separate it from the retail area.

Kopper Kitchen is quiet amid the constant flow of traffic at the corner of St. Charles Road and Route 83. The main customer entrance is boarded up, and a “For Lease” sign hangs on a few windows.

Tessa Zemgulys of the Elmhurst Chamber of Commerce and Industry said late last week that the restaurant's owner recently died, and the family is contemplating what to do with the property.

Across the street from Kopper Kitchen, shoppers may wonder if they have traveled back in time.

The Sears Essentials store has once again become a K-Mart. Mayor Pete DiCianni told the City Council Monday night that the new store is projected to generate up to $15 million in sales each year and bring about 100 jobs to the city.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Elmhurst Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Mike April 22, 2011 at 01:42 pm
Kendra & all - the Good Earth is a great deli, coffee shop & specialty grocery. They have reasonably priced items and things that Jewel and Dominicks fail to have, I hope more people support this business when they re-open again. Looking forward to them opening again. Sorry to see Fontano's close up, there sandwiches were excellent ! God bless!
Mike April 22, 2011 at 01:47 pm
Home Depot has stores in Northlake on North ave., just a few miles east of us. They also have a great store in OakBrook Terrace on 22nd street, so do not see any movement for them to open another store since we are serviced by these 2 locations. The HOME seems to have better stock and selection than Menards and is actually closer that the Hillside Menards.
Eric April 25, 2011 at 01:30 pm
Jatha,
Trader Joe's has said previously that they would not open a store in Elmhurst. As much as you or I think that it would be a success, they do not. Their business plan goes something like the following. Please forgive my numbers, they are not exact, but I think you'll see what I mean. When looking at a location for a new store, Trader Joe's requires that 70% of the population in the surrounding communities within X number of miles (likely 20 miles) have a college education before they will build. With Elmhurst, you have Bensenville, Berkely, Bellwood, Addison, Northlake, & Villa Park going against that demographic. TJ's would rather you drive to Glen Ellyn than have one in our town. It is their assumption that the population of Elmhurst alone cannot support a TJ's.
Jim Court April 25, 2011 at 01:46 pm
Eric,
Is it also possible that in excess of 30 % of Elmhurst residents do not have a college education?
Eric April 25, 2011 at 02:24 pm
Of course it's possible. I don't know the numbers, I just know what TJ's policy is. I'm not knocking other communities in comparison to Elmhurst either. Just using Elmhurst as a central location in TJ's policy.
I guess my point in the last sentence would be, given the so-called "wealth" in Elmhurst (whether actual or merely perceived), cannot support a TJ's by itself.
Eric April 25, 2011 at 02:26 pm
Also I should add, that this is according to the TJ's people.
Mike April 25, 2011 at 02:45 pm
I think a TJ store in South Elm. closer to Oakbrook might be supported well. Food stores like Jewel and Dominicks want to dominate the landscape. Trader Joe's can survive if only people give them a chance. How many people reading this story have tried Joe's - there is a store in Glen Ellyn but with gas $5 a gallon people are complacent to stay in Elm., which is ok. The Trader stores have items that Jewel and the other big box stores do not carry and it is just a different experience but believe me the big guys do not want competition and supposedly Dominick's had a coronary when Trader Joe's was searching for a Elmhurst or near west suburban location. They hate stores like that, they want to rip off the unsuspected consumer or the lazy one. If the Good Earth foodstore / deli does open, please give it a try. Thanks.
Bill Angel April 25, 2011 at 05:44 pm
Mr. Court, you are one very insighful individual. I was once in a meeting with Peter P. DiCianni III, he told us to not let a few small white lies get in the way of his good story. 2 years in a row Peter says at the Chamber breakfast, Trader Joes is coming, still waiting. Peter is recruiting some high-end food store out of Milwaukee for the space where FORD left on York, stillwaiting. Kopper Kitchen-gone, Fontano's-gone, Park Place interiors-gone, Good earth-gone, Furniture store next to Mels ACE-gone, too many others to list under Mr. D's watch. Did you know the City pays a consultant Findzall/Malony couple over $45,000 plus expenses to to RETAIN & RECRUIT business to Elmhurst. The "couple" are only required to put in 8 hours per week "working" from home. I'm just wondering when the "couple" will recruit "hiz honor" Peter P. DiCianni who runs a huge printing businesses from a storefront building on the 400 block of Addision Road, ADDISON, IL. I think the labor and taxes are cheaper in ADDISON. Peter always wants us to shop Elmhurst. How would you feel if you run Dominicks, Jewell, Fruitful Yield or other small specialty shops in town knowing Peter is bent on bringing a direct competitor to town using taxpayer money?
Mike April 25, 2011 at 05:48 pm
What exactly did the $45k buy ???????? What are the specifics on this Findzall/Mahoney deal, did the alderpersons approve this contract? Seems like a major expenditure for the City and taxpayer funds. Maybe we don't know all the facts.
Darlene Heslop April 25, 2011 at 06:46 pm
meier just opened a store in melrose park... .
Darlene Heslop April 25, 2011 at 06:56 pm
i have been in contact w/both whole foods and trader joes asking about a store here in elmhurst. there is a whole foods in hinsdale and another in willowbrook on route 83. both corporations look for particular demographics, most related to per household income and home values, as well as look at if a store will generate new customers vs. merely being convenient for current ones. both corporations feel that a store in elmhurst will not generate enough new customers, which is supported by their demographic data and a history of success within the business model. both stated that to put a new store in elmhurst would merely draw business away from current locations, and therefore those locations would become unprofitable. as for a home improvement store, the same type of market research goes on and unfortunately, we do not have the ability to support one when there are others within a 10 mile radius that would be able to serve this community. also, with home depot, they require a very large site, usually a minimum of 6-8 acres, and we don't have anyplace that big.
Bill Angel April 25, 2011 at 07:03 pm
$45K brought us taxpaying fools a job for two unemployed residents (charity) a no-bid contract for FOP. It's who you know in Elmhurst politics, not producing results. See the bogus report they submit monthly and you will actually laugh in sickness. A perfect example of truly wasteful spending. Alderpersons do what they are told by King Peter, or else! Is it not governments job to create jobs? Who cares if 50 companies leave Elmhurst. King Peter will simply raise your taxes again and again. Balanced budget? Off the backs of seniors and lost services, pot holes & asphalt filled sidewalks if your lucky enough to have them.
Mike April 25, 2011 at 07:15 pm
Why did this contract go no - bid? Maybe they can pull it for poor performance or poor results?
Darlene Heslop April 25, 2011 at 07:57 pm
the current contract is in the zoning and planning committee being reviewed, according to the committee chairman, alderman steve morley. the mahoney's have asked for a multi-year contract and a raise. the mayor has come out in support of this contract, as has alderman kevin york, basically stating that findsall is doing a great job and we need to keep them. i have asked alderman morley to put this contract out for competitive bid, but i don't know if this will happen, because after talking with several people who were at the last meeting, the consensus seems to be that the "deal is done" and what the zoning and planning committee is attempting to do is find the ways to justify it. under findzall, more businesses have left than have come...so that to me is justification enough - to find someone else to do the job, since the objective is not just recruitment of new businesses, but retention of current ones. i feel very bad for mr. o'keeffe, since i know that a small business such as his, is more than just a means to support his family, but in reality, becomes a near and dear entity unto itself, and it can be very emotional to have to give it up.
Jim Court April 25, 2011 at 10:54 pm
Has anyone noticed the blight that is the old Elmhurst Ford? Why didn't code enforcement ever do anything about it? The owner extracted every penny he could and put nothing back into the business.
Now, as a result of this we have lost the Ford dealership and will see tax dollars move to Bensenville. So much for community loyalty To the former owner of "Elmhurst Ford" Shouldn't it be called Bensenville Ford? I feel bad for Fontana's since the owner is such a decent guy. Aggressive parking enforcement and limited parking doomed a very high quality store. Three hours cumulative parking and after that get out of dodge, or you will get a ticket. Stop in get a sandwich, go about your day out side of Elmhurst, come back and eat at a restaurant and the computer will show that you have been parked all day and bingo, a ticket is issued. Shoot ourselves in the foot again and again. Drive customers away. Nice move, Elmhurst. Most of the cities processes are far behind the times and lack the creativity and innovation of towns like Wheaton. Few are customer friendly and often are adversarial. Promises of change and innovation seem empty. Maintenance of the status quo and protection of power seem our choice.
Mike April 26, 2011 at 11:43 am
To Jimbo Court - Yes I did notice the degrading condition of Elm. Ford before they closed. Although the builiding was not leaking water or anything, the parking lot and paving around the dealership was horrible. They really needed to work on that. Back in 2010 did test drive a car there and noticed the bad conditions there. I do not think the condition was that bad inside the building, but maybe ownership and Mgmt. knew the end was coming and refused to upgrade the facilities. You or I would do the same.
Jim Court April 26, 2011 at 12:47 pm
I do not believe that they knew the end was coming as you say. Elmhurst Ford was able to survive after Ford Motor Company bought out Oakfield Ford to reduce competition and also because the Lincoln-Mercury dealer was closer by on Grand Avenue.
Doors were falling off, the lot was a mess, and the mechanics were unhappy. The aesthetic of the building was very poor. Look at it now. Without the distraction of the shiny vehicles, what is left is an eyesore. The owner sold his license to Larry Roesch and now wants to dump the property. Why was the property allowed to deteriorate so badly and the City take no action? I see blight in many locations and unless someone complains, nothing is done. Are we reactive or proactive. One is about leading the other is about selective enforcement and following the rules inconsistently, which negates the integrity of the process.
Mike April 26, 2011 at 01:11 pm
Jim - I think your heart is in the right place here on Elm. Ford. but don't you think we need a little less government! We can't expect the City to inspect every single business to see if they don't have enough bathroom tissue in the washrooms, please. I am sure the Ford dealership was struggling, they were never busy when I went there last year. The place was safe but not fancy. The showroom was adequate for a car dealership. I love it when people expect the City to cure all problems, here it sounds like they ownership just closed and left it. I agree it looks bad now, but hopefully someone will come along to open a business.
Jim Court April 26, 2011 at 03:13 pm
I am often for less government but we have in place a code enforcement department that is supposed to maintain the condition of the town and help to correct blatant violations. Proactively that is, not just complaint driven. If someone complains, the wrath of government comes down on the individual yet throughout town many similar conditions exist. Code enforcement must be proactive, work with people constructively and should only issue tickets when they are following the actual codes and all attempts at remediation have been attempted. This is not the way it is done.
Aaron M. May 23, 2011 at 02:19 am
lets be honest here. The owner of Fontano's was a good guy but the whole store had no sense of business. The subs were subpar and way way overpriced. subway had much better subs n subway is the mcdonald's of subs for crying out loud. Fontano's deserved to go out of business plus they had mold all over the place.
And the economy is a terrible excuse. Chow across the street seems to be doing alright and their food is just about as expensive. The difference is Chow has great food that caters well to a more upper-class clientele so it can have high prices. Plus Oven Baked Subs opened on North and York and they seem to be having no problem having great subs at low prices. I was happy to see Fontano's close its doors. Its a joke to see average food with ridiculous prices. If the economy is bad then lower your prices.
Mike May 23, 2011 at 01:03 pm
Fontano's was a safe and good place to eat, there was no mold etc. there. He just was in the long location. Chow was a disappoint for us. We bought some trays for a graduation party a few years ago and were severely disappointed, we could have done better. We know everyone has off days and perhaps we will go back to Chow, but the food was bland.
Jim Court May 23, 2011 at 08:42 pm
Overly zealous parking enforcement made it impossible to go to this wonderful place and not risk a ticket.
Revenues from parking tickets are in direct conflict with what is good for our business establishments. Thew Mayor seems to not want to address this issue,nor does the city council Why? because it would rock the status quo and seem to be in opposition to the bureaucracy that exists. It seems that Mayors do not lead but rather go long to get along. If I were the Mayor I would tell the Police that our citizens our taxpayers that support your jobs and please treat our citizens with respect. No, I do not support criminal activities. I detest the criminal element. Try to break into my garage and see how I respond. I recently evicted people from a property who willfully and purposely destroyed the property yet the Elmhurst Police would not do anything to assist me. Thus, i must go to the DuP)age County States Attorney for adddress of this problem. Why? Because I dared criticize the Police on overly aggressive actions taken against our citizens? I think so.
Mike May 23, 2011 at 10:24 pm
It is all about venue Jim. The DuPage County States Attorney would take care of prosecution of damage to property. Guessing it is under $3k or $5k, why don't you file a claim in small claims court. It is not hard, you can do it yourself. Elm. Police have more important things to look into and quite possiblly the DuPage States Attorney might be the ones if this is a major criminal damage to property case.
Jim Court May 24, 2011 at 02:00 pm
Mike,
This same individual was picked up by the Elmhurst Police on a warrant issued by the Joliet Police after he trashed a hotel.Joliet Police acted decisively and aggressively.What is different? Small claims is not the inappropriate venue for actions that include criminal damage to property. Imagine, I rent your home and then purposely destroy the property. What would you expect the Police to do? Nothing? If I walk down the street and spray paint a fence I can be charged. What is different about the willful and malicious destruction of property ? Is this the best I can expect from the Police although I am a taxpayer on multiple properties.? Let the same thing happen to one of their homes or one of our elected officials and you would see a very different response. Illinois law is clearly on my side but the Police abdicate responsibility. I will be going to the States Attorney but I should not have to do this by myself. The Police have a responsibility which they have shirked.
Mrs. August 31, 2011 at 02:19 pm
It is August 31, 2011 - Good Earth Market has been closed now for Months. What is now going on with that? They owe my Friends TONS of Money in Michigan - a Farm that they brought produce from and never paid them. Who are these people?
Ken T August 31, 2011 at 02:26 pm
Yea, they have stringing people along since November when they closed the doors for a 'remodel' or expansion of the cafe. From what you are saying, it is pretty clear they went bankrupt...then they need to sell the property, so it doesn’t start to look like the dilapidated TCBY and Brown's Chicken on York / South street! I am disappointed though, because I really did like the store and it was very convenient to where we live in town.
Karen Chadra (Editor) August 31, 2011 at 05:08 pm
We've written a couple of stories involving Good Earth. They told us they were remodeling, that the retail store would open in May, the greenhouse was going strong, etc., etc. Last time I drove by, there was nothing in there - not even in the green house. Might be time for another followup, but the information obtained in the past has been totally unreliable.
Ken T August 31, 2011 at 05:16 pm
Funny, I was just walking to the Farmer's Market today and someone came out of Good Earth and I asked if they were ever opening up again....he smile and said 'yes, in about a month and a half.' Guess we will believe it when we see it!!
Mike Conner June 10, 2012 at 04:36 am
Kopper kitchen to reopen I think it may torn down or totally remodeled with a new fresh concept from a company from the west cost
Stewart Levine June 10, 2012 at 06:26 am
Kopper Kitchen should be re-built as a Macaroni Grill, or another nice Lettuce entertainment restaurant, i mean what gives? Oakbrook has all the nice restaurants why not bring some out this way? Anything that architecturally stands our and grabs people would make a fortune on that corner. the current building does not do that. I think an all glass building with a brittish conservatory type of atmosphere where people can be around green oxygen generating plants, sip espresso, and read books or surf the net, in the dead of winter over looking the entire intersection watching cars drive by would be neat too.
as far as sears essentials goes, or kmart? yuck. I thought this was Elmhurst. anyone remember that movie Rain Man, with tom cruise? k-mart sucks. that should be a micro center computer store like the one in westmont, or a best buy, there should be a bed bath and beyond... luxury or high end retail... what are we encouraging around here with a k-mart. k-mart should have went the way of venture. we used to have an eduardos pizza in that plaza, years ago that would be nice to have something like that...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Jim Court June 17, 2013 at 11:56 am
Claire, You present a very well thought out understanding of TIFs and your logic is impeccable.
Patty Pistone Fritsch June 17, 2013 at 02:23 pm
Can we get the name of the shelter, we work with a shelter in Oak Park, that may be able to save aRead More few of these little pups before its too late for them!
Geneva Vikings June 17, 2013 at 10:24 pm
Patty...it's Casey's Safe Haven. Reach us atcaseysdogs@yahoo.com. Any help would be great!
People Amaze Me June 14, 2013 at 08:41 am
I agree with you but I don't know if we as just citizen's can do anything to stop that practice. IRead More wish that each cyclist had to have a license, and that it was enforced by laws and police, on the bike so that people could report occurrences and have the person receive a ticket just like a person driving an auto. That would make sense.
Jennifer MacKenzie June 14, 2013 at 08:43 am
A couple of years ago, Villa Park installed "State Law- must stop for pedestrians" signsRead More on the roadways where the Great Western and Prairie Paths cross. I saw a big increase in path users barreling across the streets with no regard for the stop signs on the path.
People Amaze Me June 15, 2013 at 04:11 pm
I was really hoping that the Elmhurst Police would sound in on this info-I do understand kids willRead More be kids, but if one of them is hurt, that adult driver will need to live with that for the rest of their life-so let's come up with a solution for both bicyclist and cars to be in harmony. I really think that a step up in enforcement in the bicycle laws would help-just like the drunk driving laws-believe me the bicycle laws are just as important.