How about The Princess Bride? Seems like a shoo-in (and at 1987, sneaks in the 25-year cap.)

"French Kiss" and "An Affair to Remember"

I never considered "Groundhog Day" a romantic comedy, but if you say so, Rick, Bill Murray's classic gets my vote. ("Love, Actually" is my guilty-pleasure No. 2.)

Not sure how You've Got Mail made the list ... Not one of my picks. Would have to agree with most, but I'd put Moonstruck higher on the list.

I forget to mention "A League of Their Own" as an also-ran—although that's on the border line of romantic comedy. "Groundhog Day" was on the Moviefone or one of the other Top 10 lists. Is "An Affair to Remember" considered a romantic comedy? I thought that one was a tear-jerker. And finally, I think "You've Got Mail" might have been left off some lists because it's a remake of "The Shop Around the Corner," which is made RC Top 10 lists. I just liked that one a lot. :)

How about "Return to Me"? That's one of my all time favorites.

Moonstruck, hands down.

Tony, I am with you.

I've always been fond of "Waitress" and "High Fidelity", personally.

Groundhogs Day, with Bill Murray

I also liked the film The Road to Wellville, it is another lesser known film, but with great actors and a hilarious script. check it out on imdb or rent it if you get the time.

You have a lot of my favorites on that list, including "You've Got Mail," which I would put above "When Harry Met Sally." "American President" is one of my all-time favorites; I think I can recite most of the lines. Somehow, with "Pretty Woman," which I like all right, I get stuck on the hooker part...

And "My Best Friend's Wedding" should be on there, too.

"Officer and a Gentleman" is pretty romantic, though I'm thinking it may not be a comedy.

One of my co-workers would add "Chocolate."

And I forgot "The Goodbye Girl," and a bunch of other Neil Simon choices. Didn't Richard Dreyfuss win the Academy Award for Best Actor for that one?

No Roxanne or LA Story?!?!?!?! I'm appalled.

I added a poll, just for the heck of it.

Jabberwocky.

Hope Floats is one of our favorites also some ice skating movie with a hockey player that my daughter watched over and over........thanks nicer start to the day than snow and problems!!!

I Love You Man, if you haven't seen it you should =) http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1155056/

How about Deliverance?

The War of the Roses :)

Welcome to Mooseport

Continental Divide. John Belushi and Blair Brown. Part in Chicago, part in Colorado.

so many good ones here - I will have to rewatch some of them that I haven't seen in a while. My personal favorites are "Bridget Jones' diary", "Nottinghill" and "When Harry Met Sally".

E.t. (A boy and his alien), Brokeback Mountain (a man and his...man); Das Boot (A man and his submarine) ; Thelma & Louise (a woman and her woman [With Brad Pitt!!]); and my personal favorite Raising Arizona

I loved The Notebook.

This is the first list I have ever seen where I've actually seen every movie! If The American President or Notting Hill are on, I have to stop what I'm doing to watch them.

Just Friends with Ryan Reynolds.

No one's mentioned "The Wedding Date" yet, so I will! Also, everything on the aforementioned list with Meg Ryan, and "The Cutting Edge" (which I had totally forgotten about!).
It's not a romantic comedy, but I think the Will Ferell/Maggie Gyllenhal scenes in "Stranger Than Fiction" are downright adorable.

No one has mentioned "While You were Sleeping." That's a gross oversight. Great movie.

How about "Continental Devide"? It is a lesser known John Belishu flick.

What about "Waiting to Exhale?" VERY funny! =)

The Princess Bride- the whole premise is about twoo wuv...

"Dave," with Kevin Kline and Sigourney Weaver

"Same Time Next Year" with Alan Alda and Ellen Burstyn was cute.

"An Affair to Remember"